Stuyt Dairy Farmstead Cheese

Stuyt Dairy โ€” Mild Cheese (2โ€“4 Months)

$7.00pickup / delivery only

Stocked at 429 McHenry Ave. Fresh and cold-chain items never ship — pick it up in store, or order local delivery within 5 miles of the shop.

๐Ÿฅ› Local delivery & in-store pickup. This is a fresh, cold item. Order it here and choose Local Delivery (within 5 miles of our Modesto store, delivered after 7 PM) or Pickup at 429 McHenry Ave at checkout โ€” we keep it cold the whole way. It cannot be shipped nationally.

Young Dutch-style farmstead cheese, handmade from raw milk twenty minutes up the road.

Farmstead means the cheese is made on the same farm where the cows are milked. Stuyt Dairy makes theirs the Dutch way, in the Gouda tradition, from raw cow's milk from their own herd, then ages it a minimum of sixty days. The Mild is aged two to four months: smooth, creamy, buttery and gentle, with a clean finish. Raw milk means the enzymes and cultures in the milk stay in the cheese, which is why a young raw Gouda tastes fuller than its age suggests.

Who this is for

  • Kids' lunchboxes and after-school snacks; this is the crowd-pleaser
  • Grilled cheese and melts, where a young Gouda shines
  • You're curious about raw cheese and want the mildest place to start
  • Anyone who wants a local cheese on the board instead of an import

Details

Sold by the piece. Keep refrigerated; wrap the cut face in paper or wax rather than tight plastic. Raw cow's milk, aged over 60 days.

Made by the Stuyt family, a fourth-generation dairy family in Escalon, California, who began making cheese from their own milk in 2015.

  • ✓ Cleared the Frontier Standard — no industrial seed oils, no refined sugar, no synthetic preservatives, dyes or “natural flavors.”
  • ✓ Private, founder-owned or family-run. No publicly traded parent.
Shipping & pickup

This one never ships — it has to stay cold. Choose free pickup at 429 McHenry Ave, or local delivery within 5 miles ($7, free over $100), at checkout.

Returns

If it isn't right, tell us within 30 days and we'll make it right. Opened food and refrigerated items are the one exception, for obvious reasons.

ยทKeep looking

More from this shelf

Everything here cleared the same standard. Nothing on these shelves that we wouldn't take home ourselves.

Everything →